Dora an analysis of a case of hysteria. Dora: An Analysis of a Case of Hysteria by Sigmund Freud 2022-12-26
Dora an analysis of a case of hysteria Rating:
9,3/10
262
reviews
Dora, also known as "Ida Bauer," was a young woman who was diagnosed with hysteria in the early 20th century. Her case was famously documented by Sigmund Freud, the founder of psychoanalysis, in his book "Fragments of an Analysis of a Case of Hysteria."
Hysteria was a term commonly used in the late 19th and early 20th centuries to describe a range of psychological and physical symptoms, including anxiety, nervousness, and sexual dysfunction. It was thought to be primarily a disorder of women and was often attributed to a lack of proper sexual gratification or repression of sexual desires.
In Dora's case, Freud believed that her symptoms were the result of unresolved conflicts and repressed memories related to her sexual experiences. He believed that these conflicts and memories were causing her to experience anxiety and other psychological symptoms.
Freud used a technique called free association, in which the patient is encouraged to speak freely about their thoughts and feelings without censoring themselves, to try to uncover the underlying causes of Dora's hysteria. Through this process, he discovered that Dora had experienced several traumatic events in her life, including sexual abuse by a family friend and attempted rape by a man she had been engaged to marry.
Freud believed that these events had caused Dora to repress her feelings and memories about them, leading to the development of her hysteria. He argued that by bringing these repressed memories and feelings to the surface through psychoanalysis, Dora's symptoms could be resolved.
However, Dora's case has been controversial and has been criticized for a number of reasons. Some have argued that Freud's interpretation of Dora's symptoms was overly simplistic and that he imposed his own theories and biases onto her case. Others have pointed out that Dora was a young woman living in a patriarchal society and that her experiences and symptoms may have been shaped by societal expectations and gender roles.
Overall, the case of Dora highlights the complex and often controversial nature of the diagnosis and treatment of hysteria. It also serves as a reminder of the importance of considering the social and cultural context in which psychological disorders occur and the need for a more nuanced understanding of the experiences and needs of individuals seeking treatment.
Dora: An Analysis of a Case of Hysteria by Sigmund Freud
Freud determines that the dream was conceived as a fantasy of revenge against her father and Frau K. Mitchell 1993 , however, makes the valid point that it is easy to criticize the case study when taken out of its own conceptual context. On two occasions, Herr K. . It assumed that the psyche is motivated by basic controllers such as libido and disgust. He died of cancer on 23 September 1939.
Dora: An Analysis of a Case of Hysteria Characters
She asked a hundred times and received the same answer that the station was five minutes away. Freud discusses the techniques he used to interpret his discussions with the girl, and how her psychological condition was strognly linked to the social environment of her home and her parents friends' family. Oh, and for Dora's MAD SNARK. His discourses on theory have a nearly-scientific logic, but applying these theses to an actual person - a tragic 18-year-old upper-middle-class girl - produces a kind of disquieting surrealist novel. New York: Yale University. Unformulated Experience: From Dissociation To Imagination In Psychoanalysis. Also, no TOTES means yes, ESPECIALLY from teenagers! New York: Basic Books.
Dora is eighteen at the time of this analysis. But Freud's narration primarily centers on his process of interpretation and how he came to the conclusions he a An interesting case history about a young girl. In 1900, his major work 'The Interpretation of Dreams' was published in which Freud analysed dreams in terms of unconscious desires and experiences. The contemporary psychotherapist would see Dora as requiring a process of mourning within a secure environment Bowlby, 1988. The lady Frau K was in conflict with her husband Herr K. Years after Dora's psychoanalysis, she comes back and tells Freud of her "progress. Freud's text at times hints a what seems to be a readiness to interpret information in favor of his own pre-established ideas of the patient in t Freud is a character who remains known in psychology as well as popular culture, although most of his ideas have long been without support from the scientific community.
Dora: An Analysis of a Case of Hysteria by Sigmund Freud
It is the first of Freud's great analytic cases and the first involving an adolescent. Therefore your pain is expressed through somatic symptoms that reflect your unconscious sexual desires and if you hadn't played with your jewellery box when you were a child none of this would have happened. . Vaginal discharge is a completely normal thing for any woman who has gone through puberty, and abdominal pains? In 1923, he published 'The Ego and the Id', which suggested a new structural model of the mind, divided into the 'id, the 'ego' and the 'superego'. I get the feeling that he did want to empathize, he did want to help people get better, and he was pretty damn bright, with some of his more theoretical texts seeming to potentially lead to revolutionary ideas.
Dora : an analysis of a case of hysteria : Freud, Sigmund, 1856
The relational therapist would also expect clues and information of this sort to be communicated through an interactional process consisting of repeated cycles of projective and introjective identification. Freud's brilliant rhetoric, with a personal twist, can turn almost anything into a irrefutable repressed desire and in such, in the end I'm convinced the case study shines more light on Freud's own rep I enjoyed this piece as a fun, animated sort of thing. GradeSaver, 18 September 2008 Web. Bauer's "housewife psychosis" and self-absorption further increased Dora's alienation and desperation. Yet Freud believes otherwise. Even as it's fairly interesting to read, it's also quite obviously strangely personal. I wonder if this is a more shocking read now than it was when it was written, and I sincerely have no idea.
'Fragment of an Analysis of a Case of Hysteria ('Dora')'
Hillsdale, NJ: The Analytic Press. One is to see a Twilight-Zone-type twist: is Dora the hysterical young girl, or is Freud? But as usual, the ideas are taken too far, too arrogantly and always, always a sexual end is found especially if you are a female, of course. The richest, most infamous, and, to some, most botched case in the history of psychoanalysis is still challenging for one singularly psychoanalytic reason which the other, more superficial, reasons pale beside: Freud's insistence on the importance of the unconscious. There are further indications of Freud's counter-transferential perturbation: he lied twice and misdated the case twice in his prefatory remarks; he repeatedly errs about Dora's age and refers to her at different developmental levels "girl," "child," "woman," "female person," "lady" ; he confusedly traces Dora's coughing and aphonia to ages eight and twelve; he attributes to Dora an adult-like love of Hans during her "first years" in Merano, Italy she was there from age six to age seventeen ; and he grossly misinterprets Dora's silence as agreement when he mistakenly tells her that at age seventeen she was really fifteen , she was committed to her traumatizing seducer, much like her mother at the age of seventeen. Freud published his first major work in 1900, Freud started his research into hysteria and psychoanalysis with Joseph Breuer. But like, I'm way too much of a professional to believe that, because we have to approach these PERVERTS within the context of their OUTRAGEOUS MISUSES OF MUCUS MEMBRANE. In 1910, the International Psychoanalytic Association was founded with After World War One, Freud spent less time in clinical observation and concentrated on the application of his theories to history, art, literature and anthropology.
Dora: An Analysis of a Case of Hysteria Study Guide
K's family and Dora's family used to meet all together, and occasionally Dora's dad used to stay alone with Frau K, while Dora used to stay with Herr K and his children. Although it is not often studied today, the work provided the basis for many of the arguments that Freud made in Dora: An Analysis of a Case of Hysteria. Interaction is manifested both in affective terms and by means of the transference-countertransference process. Buy Study Guide Dora Freud's patient, whose real name is now known to be Ida Bauer. And she has abdominal pains because she is sexually attracted to a man who at times becomes ill as well.
Freud is also quite careful, in that crafty analyst way, to cover his backside at every turn, criticizing the critics before they criticize him and reminding us that this treatment was cut short and would probably have been successful had it continued. In doing so, Freud asserts that Frau K. Besides, the analysis was a failure! I think this book, although ridiculous, is rather an important read. To alleviate his lung trouble, the family moved to a small town with a mild climate, which Freud calls "B—" to protect the identity of his patient. Freud's text at times hints a what seems to be a readiness to interpret information in favor of his own pre-established ideas of the patient in terms of her intelligence, and what he believes her correct diagnosis would be. I think Dora was having a lot of losses inside her. Indeed, this search may be her real agenda and form the basis for a genuine, though predominantly unconscious, therapeutic alliance Hurry, 1998.
