Grant vs lee. Which General Was Better? Ulysses S. Grant or Robert E. Lee? 2022-12-25
Grant vs lee
Rating:
5,5/10
298
reviews
Ulysses S. Grant and Robert E. Lee are two of the most well-known figures of the American Civil War. Both men were highly skilled military leaders, and their actions and decisions had a significant impact on the outcome of the war.
Grant, who served as the general-in-chief of the Union Army, was known for his strategic brilliance and his ability to inspire his troops. He was instrumental in the Union's victory in the war, and his leadership was critical in bringing about the end of slavery in the United States.
Lee, on the other hand, was the general of the Confederate Army and is perhaps most famous for his command of the Army of Northern Virginia. While he was not able to ultimately win the war, he is still remembered for his tactical skill and his ability to inspire his troops.
Despite their differences, both Grant and Lee were highly respected by their respective sides. Grant was admired for his steadfast determination and his ability to lead his troops to victory, while Lee was respected for his bravery and his ability to keep his soldiers motivated even in the face of defeat.
In terms of their personal lives, both men were also very different. Grant was known for his humble beginnings and his modest lifestyle, while Lee was a wealthy plantation owner and a member of the Virginia aristocracy.
In the end, it is difficult to compare the two men directly. Both Grant and Lee were instrumental in shaping the outcome of the Civil War, and their legacies continue to be celebrated to this day. Whether one views them as heroes or villains likely depends on one's perspective and the side they fought for in the war. What is certain, however, is that both Grant and Lee left an indelible mark on American history.
Grant vs. Lee
Grant seems to be one of those Civil War generals, of whom there are quite a few, who did not understand the changes the rifled musket forced on tactics. Grant also developed a reputation during the war for being more concerned with his own plans than with the plans of of the Robert E. Grant then moved on to quickly capture Forts Henry and Donelson, and gain control of the Tennessee and Cumberland Rivers, thereby putting a dagger in the left flank of the Confederacy. With Jackson as his right arm, he had the confidence to divide his command and attack whenever he saw the opportunity. The exhibition, "One Life: Grant and Lee: 'It is well that war is so terrible.
Next
No Comparison Between Grant and Lee
Hancock's corps of 20,000 men started marching the night of May 20—21. The job of an Army General is to command his army to win on the battlefield. Yankee Empire: Aggressive Abroad and Despotic at Home, 115. Early planned to send the division of Maj. Emerging Civil War Series.
Next
Overland Campaign
Which position was eliminated? He also sent a small brigade of North Carolina cavalry down the southern bank of the Pamunkey to scout and harass the Union advance wherever possible. Custer's men pinned down remaining threatening enemy units and captured two artillery pieces, while pioneers energetically planked the bridge to provide safe passage for large numbers of men and horses. Although Lee fights for the Confederacy, many people greatly revered him, even to this day. Acting on his own, he bloodlessly occupied Paducah and Smithfield, Ky. After his men had rested, Sheridan brushed aside the remaining Confederate resistance in the area and marched his column to Sheridan's raid was an overall tactical success, having killed Jeb Stuart at Yellow Tavern and beaten Fitzhugh Lee at Meadow Bridge, all with relatively minimal casualties—about 625 men for the entire raid, compared to 800 Confederate. The M33 Prime Mover was a conversion of former towing versions as artillery tractors 109 units in 1943-44.
Next
Grant vs Lee: Favorite Stories and Fresh Perspectives from the Historians at Emerging Civil War
Ultimately, Grant's persistence, aggression, and simple tenacity succeeded in beating Lee, in conquering the unconquerable. Lee sent a cavalry division under Maj. The M3A3 also called Lee IV and V , featured a welded hull, a pair of GM 6-71 diesels, and fixed or eliminated side doors 322 units. Army commanding, April 30, 1864 Official Records, Series I, Volume XXXVI, Part 1, Abstract from return of the Ninth Army Corps, commanded by Maj. Australia had grand plans at one stage to raise and deploy an Armoured Division for fighting in the Western Desert and the development and production of the AC-1 was the intended vehicle. The British variants were the Grant ARV, an armored recovery vehicle obtained from disarmed Grants Mk. Find out where your enemy is.
Next
Grant vs. Lee
I, 195-6; also used at West Point prior to 1861. Frontal assaults no longer worked, but many a general seemed to think if only another division were thrown in, the result would be different. Shortly thereafter, Grant recovered from a surprise Confederate attack for which he was inexcusably unprepared , saved his army in a vicious two-day battle and won a major victory at Shiloh, Tenn. Lee is a welcome addition to the scholarship of this period of the war. Thomas, however, is another question. That night, Fitzhugh Lee maneuvered south to link up with Hampton to the west of Trevilian Station.
Next
Medium Tank M3 Lee/Grant
Lincoln's Cavalrymen: A History of the Mounted Forces of the Army of the Potomac. When asked if Lee was a good soldier and general, historian Ty Seidule, author of Robert E. Hill's Corps on parallel roads to the west. Washington, DC: National Geographic Society, 2006. So obviously he had and afflicted more casualties. Ewell's men erected earthworks on the western end of the clearing known as Saunders Field.
Next
Which General Was Better? Ulysses S. Grant or Robert E. Lee?
Advantages Of The Battle Of Antietam 116 Words 1 Pages Known as the bloodiest single-day battle in American History, the Battle of Antietam took place at Antietam creek in Maryland. . The British prototype was ready in March 1941. Yet, despite surrender by one and victory by the other, controversy continues regarding which man better represents the virtues of honor, duty, and American patriotism. New York: Da Capo Press, 1929. Finding that Lee was firmly entrenched on the far bank, Hancock's men began digging in.
Next
Busted Grant
By the time of Operation Husky campaign of Sicily , the M3 was still in use by these units, but once again, the losses were replaced by M4s, and by mid-1943, all M3s in this sector had been phased out from active units. Detractors of Grant after the Civil War generation did not invent the term; they simply exploited it to the fullest. Lee had assured Hill that Longstreet's Corps would arrive to reinforce Hill before dawn, but moving cross-country in the dark, they made slow progress and lost their way at times. William Tecumseh Sherman was able to change the course of the war in the way he was able to work and think with Grant. That marked the third time that Grant achieved national prominence. Civil War historian The publics of both sides, along with their leaders, were joined by foreign powers in focusing on the East and not caring much about what happened in the West. Had he better managed his other peripheral offensives like at Bermuda Hundred, Mobile, and Shenandoah , Grant would have probably destroyed Lee through sheer attrition.
Next
The Butcher’s Bill: Was Grant or Lee Responsible for More Deaths in the Civil War?
He was killed in action in a tank the day before Rome was liberated and is buried in the Sicily-Rome American Cemetery so very very far from his native Kentucky. In other ways, they were very much alike. A single Australian conversion 800 had been transferred by 1942 was the BARV, a beach recovery vehicle, which used the M3 chassis. The Soviets quickly realized this model was not a winner and, after one year of hard fighting realised it was hopelessly outdated. Through Lend-Lease, 2,855 units were sold to the British and 1396 were supplied to the USSR. The only visible opposition to the Union crossing was at Ox Ford, which Grant interpreted to be a rear guard action, and ordered Burnside's IX Corps to deal with it. The Soviets also recieved 130 M31 Tank Recovery Vehicles, based on the hull of the M3.
Next
Grant Vs Lee Essay
In March 1944, US army ordnance declared the M3 obsolete. After Appomattox he sent 50,000 troops to the Texas-Mexican border and provided 30,000 rifles to Mexican guerrillas. Tank crew reduced to five? Implicit in the Northern claim that Grant was fighting to free slaves is the claim that such men would naturally be free of racial bias. Lee ordered Ewell to march south on the Telegraph Road, followed by Anderson's Corps, and A. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 2002. Grant, a national general, won the Mississippi Valley Theater, saved a trapped Union army in the Middle Theater, and won the Eastern Theater with fewer casualties than incurred there by his Union predecessors.
Next