Nietzsche bad conscience. Nietzsche on Bad Conscience 2022-12-20
Nietzsche bad conscience
Rating:
6,8/10
196
reviews
Friedrich Nietzsche's concept of the "bad conscience" is a central aspect of his philosophy and has had a significant influence on the development of modern thought. According to Nietzsche, the bad conscience is a product of the human mind's ability to reflect on its own actions and to assign moral value to them. It is, in effect, a form of self-punishment that emerges from our capacity to judge ourselves and to feel guilt for our actions.
Nietzsche argues that the bad conscience is a relatively recent development in human history and is closely tied to the emergence of the concept of sin. In ancient societies, humans lived in small, tight-knit communities where there was a strong sense of social cohesion and a shared code of conduct. In these societies, punishment for wrongdoing was typically inflicted by the community as a whole, rather than by an individual's own conscience.
However, with the rise of monotheistic religions and the development of a more individualistic worldview, the concept of sin emerged. Sin became something that an individual committed against a higher power, rather than against their community. This shift in perspective led to the development of the bad conscience, as individuals began to feel guilty and punished themselves for actions that they believed were wrong in the eyes of God.
Nietzsche believes that the bad conscience has had a profound impact on human society, shaping our moral values and our sense of identity. It has led to the emergence of the "slave morality," in which individuals see themselves as weak and inferior, constantly seeking approval and validation from others. It has also contributed to the rise of self-denial and self-punishment, as individuals attempt to atone for their perceived sins.
However, Nietzsche is critical of the bad conscience, arguing that it represents a negation of life and a form of self-torture. He believes that it is a destructive force that undermines our ability to live fully and authentically. In his view, the bad conscience is a product of the idea of sin and is therefore tied to the traditional values of Christianity. As such, Nietzsche advocates for the rejection of these values and the cultivation of a new, life-affirming morality.
In conclusion, Nietzsche's concept of the bad conscience is a complex and multifaceted idea that has had a significant impact on modern thought. It represents a key aspect of his philosophy and offers insights into the nature of human morality and the role of guilt and punishment in shaping our sense of self.
The second essay: “‘Guilt’, ‘Bad Conscience’, and Related Matters” (Chapter 6)
© 2002 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. For Nietzsche, justice is exercised when the strong establish laws to enforce peace and order, offer an impersonal perspective, and therefore steer people away from any personal desire for revenge. According to Nietzsche these answers are distinguished between periods, peoples, degrees of rank among individuals as well as hypotheses and probabilities. When running a marathon, one athlete might be disappointed with themselves for not winning, while another may be pleased at completing the marathon. He argues that slave morality is the creative offspring of ressentiment, the inversion of values 1, 4, p.
Next
BAD CONSCIENCE
In a person, the Master morality vision has gone beyond the concepts of good and evil and has looked into a deeper meaning in themselves, but the master morality is not an end Analysis Of Thomas Hobbes Social Contract Theory Nietzsche evaluates the world in terms of how it really is. . Certainly, Nietzsche remarks that modern atheists are susceptible to guilt, but this is due to the Christian values that they cling on to. Enslavement of the Individual in Capitalist Society as Viewed by Marx Nietzsche's distaste for modern society is evident as he prods his reader to critique moral values, to question the values of our values First Essay, 6, p. This is a problem because Christianity presents our nature and instincts as flaws and the actions they result in as things to be avoided. Finally, punishment can be used as a weapon against people who disrupt the peace or authority figures a society. On the Genealogy of Morals by Nietzsche On the Genealogy of Morals by Nietzsche focuses on the schooling in history and philology in order to determine the origin of evil.
Next
Nietzsche's Bad Conscience
Parsons, Talcott New York, 1958 , p. It could be suggested that what is required for the development of guilt is a shared morality, rather than Christianity specifically. New York, 1962 , pp. Moreover, by way of doubling once again the difficulty for the philosopher, it comes to this: he demands from himself a judgment, a Yes or No, not about the sciences but about life and the worth of living - he learns with reluctance to believe that he has a right or even a duty toward this judgment and must seek his own path to that right and that belief only through the most extensive - perhaps the most disturbing, the most destructive - experiences, often hesitating, doubting, saying nothing. Nietzsche claims that human beings are instinctively aggressive: he argues that ancient humans were nomadic hunters who used violence and exploration to survive. .
Next
The World As My Representation: Nietzsche on Guilt and Bad Conscience
To hold this state of affairs together the human turns inward. When communities form, the same mechanism of debit and credit is in play. Nietzsche notes that two assumptions are made by this theory Genealogy, Essay II, §17. The bad conscience, then, is the feeling engendered by internalization of instincts. At this point, Christianity comes along and says that God the creditor pays the debt himself, out of love for his debtor.
Next
Donovan Miyasaki, Nietzsche contra Freud on Bad Conscience
In this chapter of The Betrothed, multiple characters morality is challenged by the idea of acting on their instincts. Thus, the instincts were turned back on the human being itself. Usually, this debt was paid back with sacrifices, festivals, and obedience to historical customs. Modern society thus conditions people to perpetually torture themselves, which leaves humanity worse off than in the past. Note you can select to save to either the free. But I'm content with having a Marcus Aurelius, Teddy Roosevelt, Eisenhower, or Manu in place, however unlikely such leaders will come again and I'm not going to hold my breath. Second, it can be used as compensation for the injured party.
Next
Bad Conscience For a Nietzschean Age: Weber's Calling For Science
They just chose to forget about it and they believed that was native. During these times social hierarchy was the most important thing and could in certain times be the difference between life and death. He discovers that the word "good" has the "same conceptual transformation" for "noble" and "aristocratic," whereas "bad" is associated with "common" and "plebeian" 1, 4, p. People in 19th-century European society tend to think that punishment is useful because it helps criminals develop a moral compass or conscience, which will supposedly make them behave, succeed in life, and achieve happiness in the long run. He thinks that people need to embrace their primal, predatory instincts and find ways to express them, so that they stop torturing themselves for having natural violent or aggressive urges.
Next
Nietzsche Second Essay: “Guilt” “Bad Conscience” and the Like Free Essay Example
But I am still reluctant to accept that something resembling existential guilt could not emerge outside of Christianity or other types of shared morality. Nonetheless they will remain fixed in the imagination of man as 'the other side of the hill' because they have been inherited from ages past: for the concepts of the age of happiness was no doubt acquired in primeval times from that condition of which, after violent exertion in hunting and warfare, man gives himself up to repose, stretches his limbs and hears the pinions of sleep rustling about him. The philosopher Spinoza 1632-1677 seems to have reflected this view in looking upon conscience as the simple sadness which accompanies disappointment. . He believes that the modern European legal system punishes people for acting on such natural instincts, which causes unnecessary suffering.
Next
Nietzsche on Bad Conscience
The marriage one completely changed my thoughts about marriage and made me think about it more. Both Weber and Nietzsche use the notions of ascetic ideals and religious needs pp. To save this article to your Kindle, first ensure coreplatform cambridge. The only difference being changes in society morality over time. Memory plays a vital role in the ability to make and keep promises. Nietzsche therefore argues that the only place for the aggression to go is inward. Perhaps they believe they could have trained harder, and that is why they blame themselves for not winning.
Next
What is a Nietzsche quote that changed your life? :) : Nietzsche
Belief in indebtedness grows as the concept of God becomes stronger, and it culminates in the Christian God. Nietzsche: The Conscience In his second essay of the Geneaology of Morals, Nietzsche attempts to identify and explain the origin of the conscience. Nietzsche thinks that aristocratic people pay their debts by embodying the skills of their ancestors, and he finds this approach healthier. It makes people suffer and hate themselves for having a natural instinct to take pleasure in inflicting violence or cruelty. Punishment just becomes some unfortunate outcome that they have to deal with, like being ill.
Next
Examining Good and Bad Conscience in Friedrich...
Returning to the topic of punishment, Nietzsche argues that some components of punishment are permanent namely, the pain and spectacle of the act , and other components are fluid namely, the purpose that the act serves. However, the northern races also had the same nature, but The Christian just made the nature more civilized. At that point, he would have to be willing to become a great actor, philosophical Cagliostro, and a spiritual Pied Piper, in short, a seducer. The guilt and suffering Raskolnikov experiences throughout the remaining sections of the novel pull him into a constant back and forth internal struggle with his conscience. The opposite of forgetfulness is memory.
Next