Was the atomic bomb justified essay. Atomic Bomb Justified Essay on Atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, Nuclear weapon, World War II 2022-12-11
Was the atomic bomb justified essay Rating:
9,1/10
1365
reviews
The use of the atomic bomb by the United States during World War II remains a controversial and highly debated topic. On one hand, the bomb, which was dropped on the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki in August 1945, brought an end to the war and likely saved countless lives that would have been lost in a prolonged conflict or invasion of Japan. On the other hand, the bombing killed hundreds of thousands of people, mostly civilians, and raised ethical concerns about the use of nuclear weapons.
One argument in favor of the use of the atomic bomb is that it ended the war quickly and saved lives on both sides. Japan was a formidable military power and had shown a willingness to fight to the death, leading many to believe that an invasion of the country would have resulted in heavy casualties for both the United States and Japan. In fact, General Douglas MacArthur, the Supreme Commander of the Allied Forces in the Pacific, estimated that an invasion of Japan would have resulted in up to 1 million American casualties and 5 million Japanese casualties. Given these estimates, it is possible that the use of the atomic bomb actually prevented more loss of life in the long run.
Another argument in favor of the use of the atomic bomb is that it was a necessary measure to bring Japan to surrender. Prior to the bombing, Japan had refused to surrender, even in the face of overwhelming defeat, and was determined to fight to the death. The atomic bomb, with its devastating power, finally convinced Japan to surrender, bringing an end to the war and preventing further loss of life.
However, there are also strong arguments against the use of the atomic bomb. The most obvious is the human cost of the bombing, which was catastrophic. The bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki killed an estimated 200,000 people, the vast majority of whom were civilians, and injured many more. The bombing also caused long-term suffering for survivors, who were exposed to radiation and experienced a range of health problems.
In addition to the human cost, the use of the atomic bomb also raised ethical concerns about the use of nuclear weapons. The bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki was the first and only use of nuclear weapons in warfare, and the decision to use them set a precedent for the future use of these weapons. The bombing also raised questions about the United States' willingness to use such devastating weapons, and the potential consequences of such actions.
In conclusion, the use of the atomic bomb during World War II was a complex and controversial decision with both pros and cons. While it ended the war and likely saved lives in the long run, it also caused significant loss of life and raised ethical concerns about the use of nuclear weapons. Ultimately, whether or not the use of the atomic bomb was justified depends on one's perspective and the weight given to different factors.
Atomic Bomb Justified Essay
Would America seem like a weak nation having power and not having the fortitude to use it or would Truman hide the technology as long as possible until it was needed. But they knew that the U. The US should not have decided to drop these atomic bombs. When other countries could not afford to buy products, the U. Germany specifically was in hot pursuit of the Atomic Bomb, the research being done was not isolated to the United States, nor was it a secret.
Free Essay: Was the dropping of the atomic bombs justified?
To enforce the Japanese surrender, therefore, the United States of America dropped the bomb. The dropping of the Atomic bomb, if not the deciding factor, played a significant role in forcing the Japanese surrender. Eager to end the war, President Harry S. I had this numb feeling, nothing would come out of my mouth, there was complete silence, nothing could describe how I felt. The dropping of the Atomic bomb in Japan was important to United States history because it was arguably the biggest turning point in modern war history. The fear caused by the use of the Atomic Bomb by Germany would have been fear of the country itself, instead of fear of escalating threats if the war did not end.
This approach takes myriad forms, but often clusters around an emphasis that, to be morally legitimate, actions in a conflict must be reasonably seen to meaningfully contribute to achieving defensible aims in a war that is itself just, and must involve or be accompanied by steps to alleviate the human cost of this effort, especially the cost to those most deserving of protection. There were many military persuasions that eventually lead to President Trueman to use the bomb. Furthermore there were also ship blockades that prevented resources from getting into Japan so that they would starve, in hope that they would surrender. Truman ordered the use of atomic weapons on Japan to help fight the war. It changed the way war takes place and introduced the amass weapons of destruction to warfare. Some think it was necessary as the country had no other choice, but some people think differently and believe that the Atomic Bomb was an unnecessary sinister and shameful act.
Was the Atomic Bombing Justified? It was reported that the emperor himself was actively working with his ambassadors to reach out to other nations, in order to bring the war to a peaceful end. President Truman was faced with a tough decision when he was faced with the terrible consequences of war, but in the end, when we look back on it, he clearly made the right choice when he decided to drop the atomic bomb. Due to the United States lack of wanting to become involved in the world problems, the United States Senate did not have the United Sates become a part of the League of Nations. The least problematic way to undertake this inherently fraught and contestable exercise seems through some variant of just war theory, which attempts to conduct moral theorizing about the use of violence through structured rationality. The Japanese military was killing thousands of Americans and showed no sign of surrender. While the United States initially sought to use precision bombing techniques against key Japanese industries to hobble the Imperial war effort, as the 8th Air Force was seeking largely to do against Germany in Europe, frustration with the modest results in the Far East — in part due to the complex weather patterns over Japan — led the United States to switch to the general use of incendiary weapons against wooden cities, dropped without real pretense of precision. Death from the massive amounts of radiation released by the explosion was uncertain—it might not claim its victims for days, weeks, months, or Atomic Bomb Justified Were the Americans justified in dropping the atomic bomb s Japan? S justified in their Decision to Drop the Atomic Bomb? Afterwards, the United States declared war on Japan, and joined allies against the axis powers.
Atomic Bomb Justified Essay on Atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, Nuclear weapon, World War II
The USA believed that they could use the bomb to manage the Soviets and hold them at bay because they would fear the destructive power of the bomb. To avenge all those American lives lost, the United States launched the Manhattan project, developing the greatest weapon created at that time, the Atomic Bomb. Two years prior in 1937, the Sino Japanese Was The Atomic Bomb Justified Essay On August 6th, 1945 history was made when President Harry S. President Truman felt that invading Japan would be a huge struggle, for Japan would do anything to protect their homeland. Truman had to make a hard decision. As such, there was a need to attack the roads, railway lines, shipyards as well as bridges. Even with the devastation caused by the atomic bombs, the Japanese had been tempted to fight on.
Furthermore, this manifestation of imposed pride caused great fear for the Allies. While dropping the atomic bomb was cruel and immoral, it was essential to ending the war in the Japanese Theatre of World War II, it established America as an even greater power, and it saved American lives. The Atomic bomb was a new technology to everyone worldwide and its raw destructive power was enough for the Japanese Emperor Hirohito to agree to the Americans unconditional surrender terms. This was just one of the important events during the battle in World War II. In 1937, an event known as the Rape of Nanjing occurred. When the United States did not know what to do with the half-finished bomb their scientists accomplished they then realized they could drop it on Japan for attacking Pearl Harbor. The reason for dropping the bombs can because of the many American lives that were lost during the attack on Pearl Harbor.
📌 Essay Example on U.S. Devises New Tech to Win WW2: Hiroshima, Nagasaki Bombed
Also, the dropping of the atomic bombs on Nagasaki and Hiroshima effectively decided the use of atomic technology for weapons for the future. In 1932, Japan was also the first country in any of the theaters of war to create. The US and Japan were in World War 2 constantly fighting each other until the US found a deadly weapon to end the war. One reason that the decision to drop the atomic bombs was justified is because the United States Atomic Bomb Dbq Research Paper the dropping of the atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Document L The Enola Gay was the plane that dropped the first atomic weapon on Hiroshima. We listened to the tiny wooden box that was shaping the world. Looking back at the dropping of the bomb, it is possible to say that it was a method of prevention in many different circumstances.
The bomb also set an example to other nations of the war of the devastation that is caused by these types of weapons. As stated previously the Americans were worried about their life and wanted to end the World War 2 by dropping the bomb. With the guidance of many scientists and political leaders President Truman made the extremely tough decision to drop the bombs. Persuasive Essay On Hiroshima And Nagasaki 965 Words 4 Pages By 1945, those involved in the Second World War were exhausted. Roosevelt and Harry S. Leahy Alperovitz,The Decision To Use The Atomic Bomb, date of publication unknown There have been many issues involved with the use of the atomic bomb because of the high cost of lives, and that it was considered to be immoral and unethical. During World War II the American bombed two Japanese cities, The American government did the right thing when they bombed Japan.
One argument that was used to support dropping the bomb was that the Japanese forfeited their rights when they aggressively attacked Pearl Harbor and committed war crimes against prisoners and the Chinese. Bombing proved to be less costly and would result in little immediate damages than it would in the long run. Although the Americans were unaware of the long term effects of the bomb, they did this in retaliation to the lives lost by a surprise attack that was not suspected. They only sent 2 of the 3 waves of attacking forces before deciding enough damage had been done. Because of these reasons there were many circumstances where either America or Japan disagreed with the other. The Japanese military government began informing civilians to throw themselves at any American Infantry in an attempt to halt the American invasion. As WWII came to a close, with Japan and the United States the only remaining countries in combat, neither showed signs of surrendering.
Was the bombing of hiroshima and nagasaki justified essay: Was The Bombing Of Hiroshima And Nagasaki Justified Essay Free Essay
So in the big picture, Truman wants revenge and Stimson wants to save future civilians. This was seen after the war when Europe was divided in half, with the east being communist and the west capitalist. Was the bombing of hiroshima and nagasaki justified essay - Video Controversy over the decision to drop atomic bombs on Japan still lingers Why did the United States feel justified in dropping the atomic bomb on Japan? Two years prior in 1937, the Sino Japanese War was in full swing. Stimson was an American Statesman, Lawyer and a Stimson served under Democrats Franklin D. The March air assault on Tokyo, for instance, is thought to have killed nearlypeople, more than those lost in either the Hiroshima or Nagasaki attacks.
