Compare and contrast fairy tale versions. Grimm's Fairy Tales and Other Versions 2022-12-10

Compare and contrast fairy tale versions Rating: 6,9/10 638 reviews

Fairy tales have been a beloved form of storytelling for centuries, with many different versions and interpretations existing in various cultures around the world. Despite their widespread popularity, however, there are significant differences in the ways that different versions of these tales are told and the themes and messages they convey. In this essay, we will compare and contrast two well-known fairy tales to explore these differences and consider the impact they have on their audiences.

One well-known fairy tale that has undergone significant changes over time is "Cinderella." In its original form, the story of Cinderella was a French folktale that was recorded by Charles Perrault in the late 17th century. In Perrault's version of the story, Cinderella is a downtrodden young woman who is mistreated by her stepmother and stepsisters. Despite her difficult circumstances, she is able to attend a royal ball thanks to the intervention of her fairy godmother, who transforms her rags into a beautiful gown and carriage. At the ball, Cinderella captivates the prince, who searches for her when she leaves at the stroke of midnight. With the help of her fairy godmother, Cinderella is able to escape the prince's grasp and return to her home, leaving behind only her glass slipper as a clue to her identity. Eventually, the prince is able to find Cinderella and marry her, and they live happily ever after.

While Perrault's version of "Cinderella" has remained popular over the years, it has also been subject to numerous retellings and adaptations. One well-known retelling of the story is the 1950 Disney animated film, "Cinderella." In this version, the story is largely the same, but some elements have been altered or removed. For example, the fairy godmother is given more of a prominent role and is depicted as a maternal figure who helps Cinderella overcome her difficulties. Additionally, the prince is given more depth and personality, and his pursuit of Cinderella is depicted as a romantic and chivalrous gesture rather than a desperate search for a lost woman.

Despite these differences, both versions of "Cinderella" convey similar themes and messages. Both stories emphasize the importance of perseverance and the power of kindness and inner beauty. They also portray the triumph of good over evil and the transformative power of love. However, the Disney version of the story is more overtly romantic and sentimental, with a greater focus on the love story between Cinderella and the prince. This version also includes more overt moral lessons, such as the importance of forgiveness and the dangers of vanity.

Another well-known fairy tale that has undergone significant changes over time is "Snow White." Like "Cinderella," "Snow White" is a story that has been told and retold numerous times, with different versions appearing in various cultures around the world. In its original form, "Snow White" was a German fairy tale that was recorded by the Brothers Grimm in the early 19th century. In this version of the story, Snow White is a young princess who is beloved by all who meet her, including the seven dwarves who take her in after she is driven out of her kingdom by her evil stepmother, the queen. Despite the queen's efforts to kill Snow White, the princess is able to survive thanks to the intervention of the dwarves, who protect her and eventually help her reclaim her kingdom.

Like "Cinderella," "Snow White" has been subject to numerous retellings and adaptations over the years. One well-known version of the story is the 1937 Disney animated film, "Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs." In this version of the story, Snow White is depicted as a more active and assertive character, who is able to escape the queen's

Compare and Contrast Fairy Tales

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

The reasoning behind this stark contrast of fairy tales is for numerous diverse explanations. In the original Rapunzel, a woman and a man is longing to have a child but they did not have any luck. When we hear or see that calming word, we automatically think of beautiful expensive ball gowns, charming handsome Princes, pumpkins turning into carriages, and the infamous ending of true loves first kiss. The original fairy tales did not have music, and did not have overlapping characters. In Rumplestiltskin a little man came to visit a beautiful girl for three nights in a row. When the prince comes to find the match for the slipper the oldest stepsister cut off her toe to fit in the slipper and the youngest one cut off a part of her heel to fit in the slipper.

Next

Compare and Contrast Fairy Tale Versions Lesson Plans & Worksheets

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

On the other hand, in the 2010 Disney movie version, Rapunzel was kidnapped from her parents by an evil witch who longed for eternal youth and found that the only way to get this was to keep Rapunzel to herself since she had the magic golden flower powers flowing through her hair. In the Brothers Grimm version the stepmother takes away her clothes and when Cinderella begs her to go to the ball that her stepsisters will be attending she mocks her "how can you go to a wedding when you're covered in dust and dirt? Learn more about Leveled Compare and Contrast Reading Passages in THIS POST: 2nd Grade Reading Toothy Toothy tasks will give students an opportunity for independent practice in a fun way! This entry was posted in In this post, I will be comparing two stories. . The good characters in fairy tales were viewed as ideal perfect characters, whereas here they are just complex humans. Remind the students to use their notes. They reunite her with her parents and lived happily ever after.

Next

Compare And Contrast Disney And Grimm Fairy Tales

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

He wanders in the forest for years until he finally meets Rapunzel and her tears miraculously fell into his eyes and he could see clearly once again. The Brothers Grimm version appears to be more in line with the Hollywood perception that is commonly held today. For example, knowing a fairy tale has a magical element, helps them to compare those elements when they are reading the different versions. Both end with Little Red and her grandmother enjoying the food she had brought over and ravishing in the thought of the wolf being gone. Her husband stole the Rapunzel for her and get caught by the owner of the garden, a sorceress. Also, in both stories she meets Prince Charming who finds her glass slipper to later put back on her foot and discover she is his true love.

Next

Compare/ Contrast Fairy Tales

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

In both stories the heroine's mother dies and the father remarries but this new stepmother has no time for her new stepdaughter and does not treat her as she does her own children but instead treats her more like a servant and gives her cruel tasks to do. The evil stepmother sets near impossible tasks for her stepdaughter and when Beauty manages to achieve these tasks the vile stepmother learns that Beauty was receiving help from her natural mother who is in the form of a cow and has the cow killed and eats it. In Stardust, several characters possessed magical powers. The Disney tale features themes of dreams, selfishness, and mental abuse via Mother Gothel to Rapunzel. Beauty and the Beast originates from the Grimm tales and is one of the most inticing tales of all. Here are some recommendations that work really well for comparing and contrasting well-known fairy tales.

Next

Grimm's Fairy Tales and Other Versions

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

List of Compare and Contrast Fairy Tales You can find several great books based on fairy tales in your local or school library. This however is after her wicked stepmother blinds her suitor and casts Rapunzel into the woods to die. There are so many amazing fairy tales that you can use to compare and contrast! Rapunzel, her whole life, dreamed of going to see these lights that she always saw on her birthday. All the daughter were beautiful, but the youngest, Beauty was the most kind of all and well rounded. . They do this to fill their minds with good positive thoughts and leave them with something to think about. She kills the cow and proceeds to eat it which represents another cruel act that Beauty is forced to endure.

Next

Comparing Fairy Tales, Old and New

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

In The Little Mermaid, the ending is a lot happier, which is a major them throughout Disney movies. She makes a deal with the husband stating that he can take all the Rapunzel he wants if she can have his first born and he agrees. When Rapunzel was born, the fairy raised her. This is of a capital interest to analyze the instrumentalization of the princesses in the advertising campaigns. However, I believe that the same essential moral of good triumphing over evil is portrayed in both versions. On a point of comparison both tales involve evil stepsisters. If this is a subject that interests you, here are some sites that should appeal to you: Kennedy, Elizabeth.

Next

Compare and contrast fairy tale versions

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

They also are clearly very manipulative in nature, as Rumpelstilskin takes several things from the little girl in return for his help, and Baloo convinces Mowgli to retrieve honey from a hive of angry bees. After a lengthy break from this, the 2010 movie Tangled brought this strategy back in a huge way. In today's society fairytales are often associated with the polished Disney movies, such has been the amount made, especially over the past decade or so. Although Rumpelstiltskin and the fairy godmother are almost completely opposites, they do in fact share some key similarities. Beauty is also transformed into a sparrow after her own death.

Next

Comparing and Contrasting with Fairy Tales

compare and contrast fairy tale versions

It is quite obvious that the Grimm originally a Perrault tale, actually is a lot more gruesome and non-kid friendly than the adapted Disney version. What does contrasting mean? Writer Writer Name Offer Chat ONLINE I am a Ph. When he had heard what had happened he threw himself off the tower and poked his eyes out on the thorns below. Rapunzel grew up thinking Gothel was her mother, and had never stepped foot outside the castle at all. Give the students a few moments at the end to record any information from the story they may want to remember for later. Overwhelm with grief, he jumps out the window and is badly blinded by the thorns.

Next