How is the constitution a bundle of compromises. Why Is The Constitution Called A Bundle Of Compromises Free Essay 2022-12-28

How is the constitution a bundle of compromises Rating: 4,7/10 784 reviews

The United States Constitution is a document that outlines the laws and principles that govern the nation. It is a document that has been amended and amended again over the years, reflecting the changing needs and values of the country. At its core, however, the Constitution is a bundle of compromises. These compromises were necessary to bring together the diverse group of states and people that make up the United States, and they continue to shape the way that the country is governed to this day.

One of the most significant compromises in the Constitution was the Great Compromise, also known as the Connecticut Compromise. This compromise was reached during the Constitutional Convention of 1787, and it helped to resolve the disagreement between the small states and the large states over representation in Congress. The small states were concerned that they would be outvoted by the larger states in the new federal government, while the large states were worried that they would be overpowered by the smaller states. The Great Compromise resolved this disagreement by creating a bicameral legislature, with the House of Representatives based on population and the Senate equally representing each state. This compromise allowed the small states to have a greater say in the federal government, while also giving the larger states a greater influence through their larger representation in the House.

Another important compromise in the Constitution was the Three-Fifths Compromise, which dealt with the issue of slavery. During the Constitutional Convention, the southern states argued that they should be allowed to count their slaves as part of their population for the purpose of representation in Congress. The northern states, on the other hand, opposed this idea because they believed that it would give the south too much power in the federal government. The Three-Fifths Compromise was ultimately reached, which allowed the southern states to count three-fifths of their slave population for representation in Congress, but not for taxation purposes. This compromise helped to maintain a balance of power between the north and the south, but it also had significant consequences, as it helped to entrench slavery in the United States and ultimately contributed to the Civil War.

There were also many other compromises in the Constitution, including the Commerce and Slave Trade Compromise, which prohibited Congress from interfering with the international slave trade for a period of 20 years, and the Electoral College Compromise, which established the system for electing the President and Vice President. These compromises, and others like them, helped to bring the diverse states and regions of the United States together and create a more cohesive and functional federal government.

In conclusion, the Constitution is a bundle of compromises that were necessary to bring together the various states and people that make up the United States. These compromises have shaped the way that the country is governed, and they continue to have an impact on the country today. While some of these compromises, such as the Three-Fifths Compromise, have had negative consequences, they were necessary to create a balanced and functional federal government that could represent the needs and interests of all the states and regions of the country.

5 Key Compromises of the Constitutional Convention

how is the constitution a bundle of compromises

And its obvious that you can't back up the statement that they wanted with anything solid. Should the legislature branch elect the president? This plan stated that each state have the same number of representatives regardless of their population. Every line I wrote was in direct response to HIS statement, which was specific whether or not you want to accept it. It was our first attempt to organized and establish roles of the national government. A COMPROMISE would have been the across the board tax cut 2% off SS AND the Business tax break allowing 100% deduction in year 1 both GOP strong positions in return for GIVING UP the Tax cuts for the top 2%. The North states proposed the introduction of import tariffs on finished products to counter competition essentially forcing South states to buy their products.

Next

How Was the Constitution a Bundle of Compromises Term Paper

how is the constitution a bundle of compromises

On May 25, 1787, fifty-five delegates from twelve states met in Philadelphia to revise the Articles of Confederation. The fourth compromise was the issue of slavery. Furthermore, the original bill of rights was not sanctimonious, nor was it pure. All of these compromises were necessary in order to get the Constitution ratified. I don't think it's "overanalyz"ing to connect two immediately adjacent sentences.


Next

FREE Essay on The constitution: A Bundle of Compromises

how is the constitution a bundle of compromises

. It could not raise money and it only had one branch Pros And Cons Of Confederation confederation was our first written constitution of the new United States of America. The founders could be expected to overturn millennia of institutional racist and sexist viciousness, to surpass their own rooted bigotry, to sell out their monstrous slaver chums and selves? The trick is to fight to the point where one achieves progress for one's ideals, even while surrendering some of what is desired. It was decided that there would be two chambers in Congress: the Senate and the House of Representatives. The GOP wanted the UI extension and the Payroll tax holiday is about as GOP as it gets. The compromise stated that each slave would count as three-fifth of a person. You started this thread admitting some compromises were "terrible".

Next

The Constitution A Bundle of Compromises blog.sigma-systems.com

how is the constitution a bundle of compromises

I pointed out that such phrasing has been used as a means to describe the constitution by historians for ages. I knew that when it was happening though. It stated that for every five slaves a state had, that state would get three representatives in Congress. However, whereas the Virginia Plan seemed to provide a greater representation of the more populous states in the national government, the New Jersey Plan was proposed by the smaller states aimed at preventing the balance of the US government from tilting in favor of the more populous states as per the Virginia Plan. Also, they agreed that all trade legislation would become binding after a two-third majority Senate approval. Constitution become a reality. I'll just say that I have no interest in allowing my sense of patriotism to turn into religious ferver and thus am not interested in founding father worship.

Next

The constitution has been referred to as a "bundle of compromises" by scholars for AGES.

how is the constitution a bundle of compromises

Many of these men seemed America for a new life and many became rich doing so. Therefore, when delegates decided that a president was necessary, there was a disagreement over how he should be elected to office. Issue: Determining population set representation in the house of representatives by the population in states. . I know what the point of my thread was, I don't need you to reinterpret it back to me, especially when you are going to do it wrong. Consequently, in an attempt to develop a genuine and all-inclusive law, the delegates adopted many concessions acceptable to all the thirteen states that dubbed the US Constitution as a bundle of compromises. But they did what was necessary to stabilize a union and then liberty had its way later anyway.

Next

Why Is The Constitution Called A Bundle Of Compromises, Essay Sample

how is the constitution a bundle of compromises

The electors would sit in an Electoral College comprising of electors representing the population of each state who would then vote for the president. Anti-federalists were concerned that the executive branch lacked enough checks and balances and might become tyrannical. Edmund Randolph, speaking for the state of Virginia, proposed the "large-state plan. Americans have been given the ability to have numerous rights such as the right to vote, recognition as a person, electing the option of both the leader and taxes of the country. Many compromises were made at the Constitutional Convention, including representation, slavery, and commercial law. .

Next

The Constitution: A bundle of compromises Flashcards

how is the constitution a bundle of compromises

Clio the Leo 1000+ posts Tue Dec-07-10 08:28 PM Response to 53. The unsuccessful article of confederation is now replaced by the newly improved constitution that is still used today. The Slave-Trade Compromise was however settling the argument on whether or not slavery should be permitted in the states. This plan proposed that there be two houses of Congress each one having representatives based on the population. These compromises have had lasting impact of this exceptional nation. I think we'll get a better picture of "no compromise" come the 112th Congress in January, which is apparantly when some here want to push these debate until.

Next

Why was the U.S. Constitution called a bundle of compromises?

how is the constitution a bundle of compromises

How does that resemble the Great Compromise, in your view? Why was the U. I have the list of those that voted against it all ready and more than once. These compromises allowed for a stronger central government while still protecting the rights of individual states and citizens. This compromise set the foundation for the Senate and a House of Representatives. Its a discussion about the validity to the idea that compromise plays a huge role in the events that led to the establishment of this country.

Next

Why Is The Constitution Called A Bundle Of Compromises Free Essay

how is the constitution a bundle of compromises

This compromise was enacted so that a. And then I pointed out compromises that were made in the crafting of the constitution that validate that statement. Even though The Articles of Confederation won the Revolutionary War, there were many problems with the plan of government. Thomas Paine never struck you as sanctimonious? The convention was sent home and the Constitution was sent to the individual states for ratifying. But to pick apart a person for saying "this country was founded on compromise" is disingenious and it also ignores historical fact.

Next