How to critique a qualitative study. Research Critique of Qualitative Research on Registered Nurses 2022-12-27
How to critique a qualitative study Rating:
6,3/10
1566
reviews
A qualitative study is a type of research that aims to explore and understand people's experiences, perceptions, and perspectives on a particular topic or phenomenon. It often involves collecting data through methods such as interviews, focus groups, and observations. Qualitative studies can provide valuable insights and understanding of complex social and cultural issues, but it is important to critically evaluate their quality and rigor. Here are some steps you can follow to critique a qualitative study:
Review the research question and purpose: Start by understanding the research question that the study aims to address and the purpose of the study. Consider whether the research question is clear and focused, and whether it is relevant and important to the field of study.
Examine the research design and methods: Next, consider the research design and methods used in the study. Was the design appropriate for answering the research question? Were the methods used to collect and analyze data appropriate and sufficient for answering the research question?
Evaluate the sample and sampling method: Consider the sample size and composition in relation to the research question. Was the sample representative of the population of interest? Was the sampling method appropriate and sufficient for the research question?
Assess the data analysis: Look at how the data was analyzed and whether the analysis was appropriate and thorough. Was the data analyzed in a way that allowed the researchers to address the research question and draw valid conclusions?
Consider the study's limitations: All studies have limitations, and it is important to consider these when evaluating the study. Were the limitations acknowledged by the researchers and were they appropriately addressed?
Evaluate the study's findings and conclusions: Finally, consider the findings and conclusions of the study. Are they supported by the data and the analysis? Are they clearly and appropriately presented? Do the findings and conclusions address the research question and contribute to the field of study?
Overall, critiquing a qualitative study requires a careful examination of the research question, methods, sample, data analysis, limitations, and findings. By carefully evaluating these aspects of the study, you can determine the quality and rigor of the research and whether the findings are trustworthy and valuable.
Qualitative Study, Article Critique Example
They link the evolution of professional ethics to reform and the working conditions of nurses within China, with specific reference to values Pang et al, 2009, p. Conclusions The article presents a small conclusion, but no separate recommendations for practice. The conclusion ought to provide closure for the reader, synthesize the content, and tie everything together to help clarify the main points of the paper. What To Look For In a Research Article. The study design is described as qualitative description to obtain factual information from participant interviews to identify cancer-related pain management needs from a nursing-based perspective Rustoen et. Poisson regression models were used in the study. No, a general audience should be the primary target for a research article.
This could be argued to be a positive strength of this study, because the authors have the local and contextual knowledge to research within this cultural arena, but have a non-partisan author as well to provide balance and a wider perspective. Age also contributed to the way students react to the ethnographer along with what he or she is and is not allowed to do Hammersley and Atkinson, 1983. It is not enough to cite previous research as a means of establishing the credentials of the study, as it were. However, a strength of this study could be considered to be the use of multiple data collection instruments, and the detail with which they are described, and their provenance accounted for. The final sample size was eight subjects who were chosen after having been interviewed by the researcher.
😠Qualitative article critique. Qualitative Research Critique Article Critique. 2022
But in order to identify this best evidence, the nurse must undertake an evaluation and critical review of research studies, to see if the research is useful and of sufficient quality to be applied to their practice Fink, 2005. If so, what is it? Nurses critique research for three main reasons: to improve their practice, to broaden their understanding, and to provide a base for the conduct of a study. This includes the choice of research setting, participants, and data collection methods. In addition, they find it hard to adapt to the hot, dry and humid weather in Malaysia. Highlighted general insights that both quantitative and qualitative studies can provide to researchers.
Critiquing Qualitative and Quantitative Research Studies Example Paper
The type of reporting may be the limitation, not the research itself. Cormack 2000 asks whether the discussion is balanced, and reading this, there does appear to be a balanced evaluation, especially of conflicts between Chinese or personal ideologies, and professional ideologies. It is important to analyze because it creates a deeper understanding of the content in a research article. Each theme is discussed sequentially in this section, making reference to key literature, and to other research which is relevant to the findings. Is there evidence that the author critiqued the literature or merely reported it without critique? This includes an understanding of the different dimensions that will support and improve patient care and treatment with respect to cancer-related pain, such as physiological, behavioral, and sociocultural needs Naga et. These suggestions can be what you think could be improved in the study or areas that need further exploration. It should also be noted that this study also addresses the familial burdens of those diagnosed with bipolar disorders and schizophrenia.
The study does not appear to be associated with any form of external funding, although the location of the research project is disclosed. Cultural differences may bring different ways of doing things that will affect all aspects of their life. Thus, the biggest cultural shock in hurdle to overcome will also be dealing with people that comes from a different culture and with the range of choice available from a day-to-day basis. The study findings section represents a means of exploring the different dimensions of the systematic review and the issues that were raised Naga et. For example, were multiple data sources used, such as interviews, observations, and documents? Was the sample size adequate? A qualitative article critique is a critical evaluation of a qualitative research study.
Research Critique of Qualitative Research on Registered Nurses
To the less research-aware reader, it would be difficult to divine this information from the title alone, and it could be argued that it would be better to include in this title a clearer indication of the nature of the study. Researchers must choose how they intend to present the resulting data, should it be statistically or based on life experiences? Discussing Evidence Based Practice And Qualitative Research Nursing Essay This essay is going to examine the importance of evidence-based practise within a health care setting. Qualitative Article Critique Example Nursing Essay In the discussion section, we consider how well the author of the qualitative article articulates the answers to the research question and how the findings are placed in the context of the reviewed literature. However, there is no indication in the author list whether or not any of them have the statistical expertise for the study. All topics are addressed with a minimum of 75% containing exceptional breadth and depth about each of the assignment topics. You should provide a brief overview of the research article in the introduction.
Patients were asked a number of questions, and the interviews were recorded and transcribed for detail Rustoen et. Feeling surprise and interest will probably be the first reaction. She underscores that her findings indicate that acupuncture can be viewed as a complex phenomenon and further studies should be conducted. Sample selection Sample selection is not discussed in any detail, which could be a weakness of the study, as mentioned above Cormack, 2000. Before my immigration, I never truly experienced the challenge of a demanding curriculum. Copy to Clipboard Reference Copied to Clipboard.
If you are here, it means you have been tasked with writing a research article critique. Methodology The methodology section does not clearly state or discuss the choice of a quantitative approach Cormack,2000. Were the findings supported by the data and were the conclusions drawn by the researchers supported by the data? Help Critique a Qualitative Article Literature Review A review of the literature was undertaken in the study, which met the philosophical underpinnings of the study and summarized the existing body of knowledge related to the research problem. The second component of the article evaluates the impact health literacy and patient trust has on controlling and maintaining glycemic control in diabetics. This suggests that they have both the clinical knowledge and experience and the research expertise to carry out such a study. The sample size is described, but no details are given of how the participants were recruited, which does not allow the reader to evaluate this process and its appropriateness.
Did the researcher stipulate that information redundancy was achieved? Is the literature review current? Various types of pain analysis were used to draw conclusions regarding pain and how it impacts quality of life Naga et. Qualitative research is no less important when discussing the medical or behavioral care to be given to patients Critiquing Qualitative and Quantitative Research Studies Example Paper. Develop a Preliminary Outline It is a plan for structuring and organizing the element that constitutes the focus of your argument in the research article. Qualitative Research Critique Article Critique The conclusion provides a simple yet concise summary of the study and its findings for future consideration Naga et. For example, a longitudinal perspective could produce more solid evidences on the effectiveness of acupuncture as a treatment to substance abuse, although this was properly acknowledged by the researcher at the end of the report. The accurate replication is very difficult to achieve because an event in natural setting cannot be reproduced. Used examples from articles Formulated a response to the claim that qualitative research is not real science.
Overall, the literature review is written from an interpretive definitive voice e. Applies meaning to the field of advanced nursing practice. Conclusions or Suggestions In this section, you should summarize your overall evaluation of the research article. The study relates the findings back to a wide range of other research studies, which is a strength of this part of the report, showing congruence with many other findings in relation to quality of life, age, socioeconomic status, social support, antiretroviral treatment, symptoms, and self-care Tangkawanich et al, 2008 p. Criteria differ for critiquing a quantitative versus a qualitative study ie, statistics are evaluated in a quantitative study, but not in a qualitative study.
