Should juveniles be tried as adults. Should Juveniles be Tried as Adults? 2022-12-12

Should juveniles be tried as adults Rating: 7,4/10 423 reviews

The question of whether juveniles should be tried as adults is a complex and controversial issue that has been debated for many years. On one hand, some people argue that juveniles should be treated as adults in the criminal justice system because they are capable of committing serious crimes and should be held accountable for their actions. On the other hand, others argue that juveniles are not fully developed mentally and emotionally and should not be held to the same standards as adults.

One argument in favor of trying juveniles as adults is that they are capable of committing serious and violent crimes. There have been cases where juveniles have committed murders, sexual assaults, and other violent crimes, and many people believe that these individuals should be held accountable for their actions. They argue that allowing juveniles to be tried as adults serves as a deterrent to other young people who may be considering committing crimes.

Another argument in favor of trying juveniles as adults is that it can provide a sense of justice for victims and their families. When a juvenile commits a serious crime, the victim and their loved ones may feel that the punishment does not fit the crime if the juvenile is not held to the same standards as an adult. Trying juveniles as adults can help to ensure that justice is served and that the perpetrators of these crimes are held accountable for their actions.

However, there are also strong arguments against trying juveniles as adults. One of the main arguments is that juveniles are not fully developed mentally and emotionally, and therefore should not be held to the same standards as adults. The human brain continues to develop and change until a person is in their early to mid-20s, and this can impact decision-making and judgment. Therefore, it may be more appropriate to treat juveniles as minors who are in need of rehabilitation rather than punishment.

In addition, there is concern that trying juveniles as adults can have negative impacts on their development and future prospects. If a juvenile is tried as an adult and sentenced to prison, they may be exposed to more hardened and experienced criminals who can have a negative influence on their development. This can lead to a higher risk of recidivism and a greater likelihood of future criminal behavior.

Overall, the question of whether juveniles should be tried as adults is a complex and controversial issue that requires careful consideration. While there are valid arguments on both sides, it is important to weigh the potential consequences and impacts on both the juveniles involved and the broader community. Ultimately, the decision to try a juvenile as an adult should be made on a case-by-case basis and take into account the specific circumstances and characteristics of the individual in question.

Should Juveniles be Tried as Adults?

should juveniles be tried as adults

Under this policy, young killers could be back on the streets at the age of 21, ready to commit more crimes. But those who oppose trying juveniles in an adult court argue that it does not benefit the suspect or the society, if they are punished the same way as adults. The 15 year old boy was tried as an adult because he stabbed to death a minimart clerk. According to Regoli 2019 , keeping juvenile offenders in adult facilities poses genuine risks to the safety and well-being of those involved. Brings justice to the victims Some offenses may be forgivable, but not for extreme crimes similar to what the Wisconsin girls committed. These families and the victim will feel traumatized and be forced to stay alert and watch every move they make to stay safe. Opposers of this judicial approach against juvenile delinquency argue that making mistakes when younger is a normal part of being a teen or young adult, and it happens to even the most severe adults.

Next

Search

should juveniles be tried as adults

Second, adolescence is a period of potential malleability. Now she can live anywhere despite being a convicted triple homicide offender. There is the Author s Name: Avni Kapoor Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University. When juveniles receive a trial in an adult court, then there are more constitutional protections that apply to their case. The juvenile court operates under the presumption that offenders are immature, in three different senses of the word: Their development is incomplete; their judgment is less than mature; and their character is still developing. What they do not get is a panel that is reflective of their age group. Many believe that this is the wrong approach to take up asit does not focus on the main factor at hand — the crime that has been committed.

Next

Sentencing Juveniles as Adults is Not Always The Best Policy

should juveniles be tried as adults

This act gave state prosecutors the alternative of transferring juvenile cases that were violent or had gang involvement to the adult court without any judicial reviews Free 159. This is a tough one to follow through considering that there are several arguments to put forth on both sides. When youth receive a waiver into the adult system, then these requirements can disappear. For everything an individual has done, it is only fair that they get a punishment. We understand that the courts try to safeguard children because it considers children incapable of protecting their rights on their own, but its high time they realize and more importantly set a boundary and some kind of categorization among children who are really in need of help and the ones who twists and turns the provisions to their whims and commit crimes and then have this protective nature towards children as a victim card.

Next

SHOULD JUVENILES BE TRIED AS ADULTS?

should juveniles be tried as adults

The United States requires that you be at least 18 to be empaneled onto a jury, so having someone judge the content of a case from a different perspective may not result in a fair trial. They worry that such a significant change in the justice system would make it unsafe for those under 18. The law was able to realize this and change for the better. Raising the age furthers the likelihood of nonviolent juvenile offenders becoming functioning members of society who understand the results of their actions, and decreases their chances of recidivism. Essentially, juveniles are emotionally immature and might not clearly understand their crimes.

Next

19 Advantages and Disadvantages of Juveniles Being Tried As Adults

should juveniles be tried as adults

How much more does the juvenile delinquency rate has to rise before we realize action is required? Prosecutors and investigators see lying or criminal decisions as an adult response when there may not be an understanding of what is happening to them. Answer: A juvenile offender must be sent to the rehabilitation center for reformation rather than in jails for punishment. Why is it always that the justice system in this country points fingers and creates unprincipled assumptions about juveniles? Crime rates could get lower if minors are punished for committing crimes. His conviction was eventually overturned on appeal, which led him to receive 10 years of probation and one year of house arrest. Even when a minor shows no remorse for the crime committed, the court still has the tendency to exercise leniency.

Next

Should Juveniles Be Charged As Adults?

should juveniles be tried as adults

The Supreme Court of the United States has ruled that convictions of juveniles under the age of 18 that involve a life sentence are too severe. It offers a suitable penalty for severe crimes that some juveniles commit. For the past 100 years, American society has most often chosen the first approach. This number is down 58% since 2008, so it remains very high. An adult crime can be murder, armed robbery, and the position of drugs. . Here are a few pointers that will help you understand why eradicating the juvenile system might be considered a negative factor.

Next

7 Top Pros and Cons of Juveniles Being Tried As Adults

should juveniles be tried as adults

When children are charged in the juvenile justice system, there is a general responsibility of the parent to find appropriate care and counseling to facilitate rehabilitation. When children are tried in juvenile court, then the judge presiding over the case will have the final decision as to what the outcome of the proceedings will be. It was as early as 1899 when the United States began creating the first courts for youth offenders. Nearly every year, the FBI arrests more than 33,000 young adults under the age of 18 for offenses. It is believed that the juvenile courts are established keepingage factor in mind rather than focusing on the crime factor. There is a risk that they may never change while in jail and ultimately lose the opportunity to prove that their minds can be rehabilitated and changed for the better.


Next

Should Juveniles Be Tried as Adults?

should juveniles be tried as adults

Alexander Crisostomo was ordered to stand trial as an adult for killing a 41-year-old man when he was just 15. The general argument that underlies these changes is that juvenile offenders should be held accountable for their criminal behavior by receiving punishments that are equivalent to their crime. There has been a lot of controversy towards the subject of juveniles in the Court Justice System because many feel that juveniles are to young to be entangled with the law. Many also believe that the age limit is quite high 18. Prison can become a place where youth really learn what it means to become a criminal. Attacking juvenile crime lowers the overall crime rate and allows us to live in a society that is much safer.

Next