What to compare and contrast. Compare and Contrast 2022-12-08
What to compare and contrast Rating:
Isaac Asimov's science fiction novel "The Fun They Had" is a poignant and thought-provoking commentary on the impact of technology on society. The story follows a young girl named Margie as she becomes fascinated with a rare book that contains traditional, printed pages. In a world where all information is accessed through electronic screens and education is fully automated, Margie's discovery sparks a sense of nostalgia and longing for a different way of life.
As the story unfolds, Asimov presents a bleak vision of the future where the joy and curiosity of learning has been replaced by a sterile, efficient system that lacks humanity. Margie's teacher, Mrs. Jones, is a perfect example of this, as she is more concerned with meeting the quotas of the computerized curriculum than fostering a love of knowledge in her students.
Despite this, Margie remains determined to learn and understand the world around her. She is drawn to the physicality of the book, with its textured pages and musty smell, and she becomes engrossed in its contents. As she reads, Margie begins to realize that the world of the past was not perfect, but it was a place where people could express themselves and engage with each other in meaningful ways.
Asimov's portrayal of the future in "The Fun They Had" is a cautionary tale about the dangers of relying too heavily on technology. While it can certainly have its benefits, Asimov suggests that it is important to preserve the human element in education and society. Margie's love of reading and learning, despite the obstacles she faces, serves as a reminder of the joy and fulfillment that comes from intellectual curiosity and exploration.
In conclusion, "The Fun They Had" by Isaac Asimov is a thought-provoking exploration of the impact of technology on society. Through the character of Margie, Asimov reminds us of the importance of preserving the human element in education and the joy that comes from learning and engaging with the world around us.
5 Fun Compare and Contrast Whole Group Activities
Click the button to sign up for my email list and get this activity sent directly to your inbox! Then, when they have some experience with it, you can move forward with comparing and contrasting stories and texts! The text must do both to be considered compare and contrast. Two Settings — from the same book or different books 5. If the text only discusses similarities, it is only comparing. For this activity, you will want to read one version of a story aloud. It is clear that these objects are closely related to each other.
Overlap the hula hoops to create a physical Venn diagram. Here are two ways that you might also use a Venn diagram: A. They will notice that if there are two cards that are similar one from each story or topic that those are shared traits. Because students typically know the original story, they are able to notice key differences in the story elements. When you want a larger, more visual Venn diagram, you can make one on the ground using hula hoops.
This activity has two printable books and accompanying compare and contrast graphic organizers. Today, I am going to talk about 5 compare and contrast activities that are both fun and effective! Sometimes I tell students which set to choose and sometimes I let them decide. What to compare using a table format? The cards could have two different foods like hamburgers and hot dogs , two different animals like a hippo and a rhino , two different jobs like a doctor and a teacher or two different sports like baseball and football. For compare and contrast, I especially like task cards because they give students an opportunity to practice with shorter texts. Likewise, if it only discusses ways that the things are different, it is only contrasting. Click here to see the One of my favorite units for 3rd — 5th grades comes in both print AND digital and includes lots of paired texts with folktales, fables, and myths.
After groups are finished, I like to have kids move around the room, from Venn diagram to Venn diagram, to see what other students were thinking and how their Venn diagrams were similar or different. Use Hula Hoops on the Carpet Similarly, you can create a hands-on way to compare and contrast with hula hoops! For example, each day they quickly compare and contrast menu items in the cafeteria, video games to play, books to read, and favorite sports to play. Here is a simple Here is a more complex set of Learn More About Text Structure Text Structure Worksheets and Activities Compare and Contrast is a text structure or pattern of organization where the similarities and differences of two or more things are explored. I really love to use this when small groups are working on comparing two characters from the same book like Auggie and Via Pullman from Wonder or comparing two different books like Hatchet and The Sign of the Beaver. However, here are some signal words that may indicate that the text is written using the compare and contrast organizational pattern: like, unlike, both, neither, similar, and different. Comparing and contrasting is an important cross-curricular skill that all students need to master.
I may read two of my favorite compare and contrast books on two different days: Oliver Button is a Sissy by Tomie dePaola and Amazing Grace by Mary Hoffman. Plus, it allows the physical separation and joining of elements that reinforce the skill! Students can add differences and similarities by writing them on index cards or small pieces of paper. Buddy Class Friends, Classmates, The Classroom Teacher, and the PE or Music Teacher if you have one 3. My goal with this website is to share teaching ideas that will strengthen your teaching and provide materials that will simplify your life. They can keep their sticky notes or notecards in a folder or clipped to the book.
Scaffold Learning by Using Passages, Short Stories, and Then Books Like anything we do in the classroom, helping students advance in a skill can be done step by step with lots of direction and support at first. I prepare baggies with the same cards for each set of pairs. Edit This worksheet can be edited by Premium members using the free Google Slides online software. Compare and Contrast Graphic Organizer Identifying when the writer is comparing and contrasting is usually not difficult because the speaker will bounce back and forth between two subjects and this pattern is generally pretty easy to recognize. Place several of these in small baggies one baggie for each pair and students pull a card and compare and contrast each set. Edit This Worksheet Editing resources is available exclusively for KidsKonnect Premium members.
They tend to see this format as fun and adding a board game or a class scavenger hunt adds to their enjoyment. However, it is also evident that each object has characteristics that distinguish it from the other one described. Have them record important things about stories they read. Objects, Animals, People, Places 2. On the other hand, oranges are pulpy while offering more vitamin C. Apples and oranges are some of the popular fruits because they are accessible and easy to eat.
The challenge then is to take that skill that students use quite often and help them understand how to apply it to a piece of literature or informational text. As pairs walk around the room, they stop at each Venn diagram and write a similarity between the two objects, animals, people, or places and a difference. In order for your students to nail down this skill, you will need to provide a variety of opportunities for application. The Book and the Movie 5. Have students look for similarities and differences in the two stories! Use a Table Besides Venn diagrams, I think tables are one of the best ways to record comparisons. Apples are crunchy in general and have more fiber. If the text only discusses similarities, it is only comparing.
Using Task Cards and Games I do like to use task cards with every concept I teach. One thing I like about this, besides being a different way to record similarities and differences from Venn diagrams, is that students do need to know how to read and use a variety of text features and by using a table, it is helping students become more familiar with how a table works. Click here to see the. Once all students are familiar with the books, we go through a few of the possible categories to compare and contrast together. Unlike theme or the main idea which can be tricky, students seem to grasp comparing and contrasting much more easily.
Before I have students do this in pairs or small groups of three, I do like to model the process together. Each unit comes with everything you need to teach RL. As students progress, they become more independent workers who are able to apply the skills learned and to finish tasks on their own. I ask students to make three observations from their graph, and this is where they compare and contrast to complete the assignment. Have your students practice comparing and contrasting with two teachers, popular pets, movies or games, etc. Even though I am asking them to compare a number of things, I only ask them to record one set of observations.