Deep play notes on the balinese cockfight. Deep play: notes on the Balinese cockfight (1972) 2022-12-29
Deep play notes on the balinese cockfight Rating:
9,6/10
1046
reviews
Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight is an essay by cultural anthropologist Clifford Geertz, in which he explores the significance of the Balinese cockfight as a cultural practice.
In the essay, Geertz argues that the cockfight, far from being a simple form of entertainment, serves a number of important functions in Balinese society. For one, it provides a means of social organization and communication, serving as a forum for people to come together and interact with one another. Additionally, the cockfight serves as a way for individuals to assert their status and identity within their community, as successful cockfighters are often seen as respected and influential members of society.
Geertz also notes that the cockfight serves as a way for Balinese people to express and explore their cultural values and beliefs. The cockfight is infused with symbolism and meaning, with the birds themselves being seen as representatives of the forces of good and evil, and the outcome of the fight being seen as a reflection of the cosmic balance. In this way, the cockfight serves as a way for the Balinese people to come to terms with the fundamental mysteries of life and death, and to make sense of the world around them.
Finally, Geertz suggests that the cockfight serves as a way for the Balinese people to engage in what he calls "deep play," or the pursuit of activities that are not based on practical considerations, but rather on a desire for pure enjoyment and meaning. Through their participation in the cockfight, the Balinese people are able to experience a sense of transcendence and connection to something greater than themselves.
In conclusion, Geertz's essay Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight offers a rich and nuanced exploration of the cultural significance of the Balinese cockfight. It highlights the many ways in which this practice serves as a means of social organization, identity formation, cultural expression, and deep play, and provides insight into the complex and multifaceted nature of Balinese culture.
Deep Play Notes On The Balinese Cockfight Analysis
He benefitted from the specific insights of many individuals while analyzing their culture. Brutus is keen on relying on his own reason and his awareness of his honorable obligations as a Roman to do what is necessary. Instead, culture can be explained through the rules that dictate how individuals interact through these activities. This quotation encompasses his broader and more nuanced argument that cockfighting is both a reflection of Balinese society and a creator of it, a portrayal and a generator all at once. Having argued that cockfighting is both a reflection of Balinese society and a producer of its structures, Geertz imagines that an individual who grows up around cockfighting is simultaneously influenced by his own society and able to "read" his society as if from the outside. Actually, it is men.
Clifford Geertz Deep Play: Notes On A Balinese Cockfight Essay Example
He also describes the timing device used during the match — a punctured coconut in a bucket of water, which takes approximately 21 seconds to sink and denotes the time the cocks have to engage one another. For them, and to a degree for ourselves, we were nonpersons, specters, invisible men. This how deep their connection is with these cockfights. The ethnographer describes the way they ran with his wife away from where they got their accommodation due to the fact that during the cockfight, they were not on that side of the ring that faced the home in which they were accommodated. Different cultures have their own symbols which have specific meaning that pertain their traditions and way of life. We were intruders, professional ones, and the villagers dealt with us as Balinese seem always to deal with people not part of their life who yet press themselves upon them: as though we were not there. In fact, one might come away from the article with a greater respect for Balinese conduct during cockfights than for American fans' behavior at football games.
Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight Summary
Although in most circumstances Machiavelli and Plato disagree, occasionally, they agree. The Balinese cockfight is only one extraordinary example of this. The level of detail that Geertz provides communicates to the reader how structured, organized, and serious the cockfights themselves are. Everywhere else I have been in Indonesia, and more latterly in Morocco, when I have gone into a new village people have poured out from all sides to take a very close look at me, and, often, an all-too-probing feel as well. Geertz credits her with invaluable insight on this project in Bali.
Analysis Of Clifford Geertz's Deep Play: Notes On The Balinese...
Geertz focuses on the imagery of fighting and rage, of course, but also on that of honor, strength, constancy, and nurture. As one can see the work of an anthropologist is not an easy profession. It is only after they flee a raided cockfight that the villagers begin to accept them into their community. For a full description of the license, please visit. The ethnographer used very appropriate methods of conducting the study which has adequately addressed the research problem.
Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight Imagery
At the time, cockfights were illegal in Indonesia, as they had also been under The next day, the village opened up to the couple. In so doing, he suggests that masculinity in Balinese culture is more complex than Western readers might originally perceive, just as it is across all societies where conceptions of gender have evolved. By risking his health and safety to observe the fights, he proved his trustworthiness to the locals, allowing him to receive firsthand insight into the symbolic significance of the fights in Balinese culture. . While Bentham was philosophizing a theory of happiness, Geertz uses this concept to analyze cockfighting as a nuanced endeavor that encompasses the complexity of Balinese culture. The author analyzed the behaviors of the people towards the cockfights so that an outsider would be able to get the meaning. The consequence of this fear is one of the reasons cockfight was illegalized.
Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight Characters
Ethnography is only one form of research performed by anthropologist; although named at times the most difficult to conduct for its many varying reasons that have to do with studying a persons life up close. Regarding the emic perspective, he uses the point of view of an insider to explain the motivations and cultural implication of this event. Instead, Geertz suggests that the entire fight — including the nurturing of the cocks, the strict rules, and the wagering that occurs both inside and outside the ring — is a recreation of Balinese society at large. The foundational hindrances incorporate both the heritage of prejudice and emotional financial changes that have fallen with lopsided seriousness on poor blacks. Provide brief descriptions of the work that each part is doing and how it goes about doing it.
Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight Quotes and Analysis
But they acted as if we simply did not exist, which, in fact, as this behavior was designed to inform us, we did not, or anyway not yet. However, the Balinese negates such ideas by implying that in this play, money is not measured as a source of utility, but "a symbol of moral import, perceived or imposed". . The strong evaluation as well as the subject-referring imports as a basis of such evaluation are strongly affective on human beings and their respective lives. It was the turning point so far as our relationship to the community was concerned, and we were quite literally 'in. You have crossed, somehow, some moral or metaphysical shadow line. He adds layer upon layer of thick detail regarding the actual meaning and the context of the cockfights, resulting in a colourful narrative that illustrates the importance and meaning of these events and what they symbolize for Geertz uses the Balinese cockfight as a fulcrum around which he builds a multi-faceted description of Balinese culture.
An anthropologist must be able to observe the in-depth content of human nature within a society, analyze it from all aspects, and perform cross-cultural comparisons. Clifford Geertz's Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight manifests the notion that cultures possess rituals that are implicit, resulting in anthropologists attempting to interpret the importance of customs embedded in specific cultures. We selected three theories and will provide an overview of each theory separately. Almost nobody greeted us; but nobody scowled or said anything unpleasant to us either, which would have been almost as satisfactory. How is this essay constructed? Men spend their time grooming, feeding, and ensuring that their cocks are able win on their behalf. The essay "Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight" is written by a well respected anthropologist by the name of Clifford Geertz, who details his observations of the Balinese culture. And, as with those other embarrassments -opium smoking, begging, or uncovered breasts-it seeks,.
It seems the village chief was seen as responsible for the illegal cockfight since he was the government representative at the village level and therefore was expected to ensure rule of law. According to the records of the ethnographer, a cockfight is a blood sacrifice offered while chanting takes place in the process of the fight. Because of his positioning himself as an insider, the locals naturally trusted him and explained their customs to him. The elite, which is not itself so very puritan, worries about the poor, ignorant peasant gambling all his money away, about what foreigners will think, about the waste of time better devoted to building up the country. However, Geertz makes a point to differentiate cockfights from Western sports by acknowledging how, despite the brutality at the center of the ring, the spectators and handlers themselves are markedly composed and respectful. The Umpire In Geertz's elaborate description of cockfighting and its rules, he singles out one figure — the umpire — as playing an especially important role. Discussion The theoretical perspective of the ethnographers offers a colorful analysis of the data.
Deep Play: Notes On The Balinese Cockfight Analysis
Because the cocks are a metaphorical representation of the men, they are given the best care and much importance so much that they even have traditional folklores on cocks. In Balinese villages, at least those away from the tourist circuit, nothing happens at all. Although Richard Wright, whose… W. He described a scenario in which his wife and he were in a squall of wind stage and that he doubted whether it really existed as human beings. In the final two section of Geertz essay he states what he believes the cockfights truly represent by relating the cockfights to modern forms of art. Rather than treating the cocks cruelly like any other animal, they treat them with a tremendous amount of care and respect, even beyond that of fellow humans.
