The chrysanthemums critical analysis. Formal Analysis of John Steinbeck's 'The Chrysanthemums' 2023-01-01

The chrysanthemums critical analysis Rating: 6,5/10 420 reviews

"The Chrysanthemums" is a short story by John Steinbeck, published in 1937. It tells the story of Elisa Allen, a disappointed and disillusioned woman living on a ranch in California with her husband, Henry. Elisa is a skilled gardener who takes pride in her chrysanthemum flowers, which she cultivates with care and attention. However, despite her love for her flowers and her husband, Elisa feels unfulfilled and unappreciated in her domestic role.

One day, a tinker arrives at the ranch looking for work. Elisa is initially wary of the stranger, but she is drawn to his charismatic personality and his appreciation for her chrysanthemums. The tinker offers to buy some of Elisa's flowers, and she eagerly agrees, feeling a sense of pride and purpose as she sells her prized creations.

As the tinker leaves, Elisa watches him go with a sense of longing and regret. She realizes that she has been yearning for something more in her life, and that her flowers have been a way for her to express her own creativity and individuality. However, she also knows that her desire for something more will never be fulfilled within the confines of her traditional gender role on the ranch.

The chrysanthemums in the story symbolize Elisa's own suppressed desires and aspirations. They represent her longing for a life beyond the expectations placed upon her as a woman in a male-dominated society. Despite her talents and passions, Elisa is trapped in a narrow and constricting role, and she can only find fleeting moments of fulfillment and expression through her flowers.

The tinker's visit serves as a catalyst for Elisa's realization of her own discontent and frustration. He represents a potential escape from her mundane and unfulfilling existence, and his appreciation of her flowers gives her a glimpse of the appreciation and validation that she craves. However, the tinker's departure serves as a reminder of the limitations and obstacles that stand in the way of Elisa's dreams and ambitions.

Through the character of Elisa Allen, Steinbeck explores themes of gender roles, identity, and the human need for self-expression and fulfillment. "The Chrysanthemums" is a poignant and powerful portrayal of the ways in which societal expectations and norms can stifle and suppress the potential and individuality of individuals, particularly women. It is a poignant and thought-provoking work that invites readers to consider the ways in which gender roles and expectations shape our lives and our sense of self.

The Chrysanthemums is a short story written by John Steinbeck that was first published in 1937. It tells the story of Elisa Allen, a woman who lives on a ranch in California with her husband Henry. Elisa is a strong and capable woman who takes care of the ranch and her husband, but she feels unfulfilled and trapped in her role as a housewife.

One day, a tinker comes to the ranch looking for work and Elisa is immediately drawn to him. She is fascinated by his independence and his ability to roam the country, and she begins to flirt with him. The tinker responds to her advances and the two of them share a moment of connection. However, when Henry interrupts the moment, the tinker leaves and Elisa is left feeling even more trapped and unfulfilled than before.

Throughout the story, Steinbeck uses the chrysanthemums that Elisa tends as a symbol of her own life. The flowers are vibrant and alive, but they are also trapped in their pots, unable to roam or grow freely. This mirrors Elisa's own feelings of confinement and longing for something more.

One of the main themes of The Chrysanthemums is the isolation and confinement of women in traditional gender roles. Elisa is a strong and capable woman, but she is expected to stay at home and take care of the ranch while her husband goes out to work. This lack of autonomy and opportunity for self-expression leaves her feeling unfulfilled and frustrated.

Another theme of the story is the power dynamics between men and women. Elisa's husband Henry is portrayed as a strong and confident man who dominates the relationship. He controls the finances and the direction of the ranch, and he dismisses Elisa's interests and desires. This dynamic is further highlighted when Elisa flirts with the tinker, who represents a potential escape from her restrictive life. However, the tinker ultimately rejects her advances, further reinforcing her sense of isolation and powerlessness.

Overall, The Chrysanthemums is a powerful and poignant exploration of the struggles and desires of a woman trapped in a traditional gender role. Through the character of Elisa and the symbol of the chrysanthemums, Steinbeck highlights the isolation and confinement that many women face, as well as the longing for something more that is all too often suppressed.

Critical analysis of the chrysanthemums Free Essays

the chrysanthemums critical analysis

Therefore, Elisa spends the majority of her time alone, tending to the domestic chores and takes care of the gardens. This quote states that a person should total control of themselves and then they will find freedom. The action of the story takes place on a single Saturday right at the end of the year. As she converses with the tinker, notice how she becomes a strong and vibrant Gender roles in the society limit what each gender can or cannot do. When writing a critical analysis, you must first complete a critical reading of the work.

Next

A Summary and Analysis of John Steinbeck’s ‘The Chrysanthemums’

the chrysanthemums critical analysis

The strongest symbol for Elisa herself is found in the empty pot, whose flowers have been discarded at the end of the story. Programs stemming from the New Deal, such as the Farm Security Administration and the Social Security Administration, provided social support for the poor, the unemployed, and the elderly. Initially, Elisa is kind and seemingly excited for a bit of company. His rejection of the flowers reflects the way society has rejected women as nothing more than mothers and housekeepers Dickinson 4. Elisa is attracted to the tinker's independence and freedom, and she even feels a sense of envy towards him.

Next

Analysis Of The Chrysanthemums English Literature Essay

the chrysanthemums critical analysis

The children do not know whey they are angry by the flowers but the flowers represents the only hope, beauty and life amongst their life in the dust. Her flowers were cast out onto the road as God cast out Adam and Eve. Without her chrysanthemum she feel loneliness and her confident disappear, when she no longer in that garden. In the opening chapters of The Chrysanthemums, Elisa is seen heartily in a great degree tendering to her gentle flowers. The joys Elisa has in this world are her chrysanthemums and the chance to be able to escape her containment and join the public sphere. At the beginning of the story, Elisa is described as a strong and capable woman who takes great pride in her chrysanthemums, which she raises in her garden. Her husband, Henry, has the ranch to give him a sense of accomplishment; however, Elisa has only her flower garden.

Next

The Chrysanthemums Analysis

the chrysanthemums critical analysis

She glances briefly at the strangers standing by the tractor shed who are talking with her husband. And I can beat the dents out of little pots. Emblazoned on the canvas of the wagon's sides are advertisements that are clumsily and crookedly painted. His interpretation of what Elisa has uttered about her flowers he translates into rough, dangerous language. Such is the introduction to frustration and significant limitations women face, as Steinbeck depicts in Elisa.


Next

Formal Analysis of John Steinbeck's 'The Chrysanthemums'

the chrysanthemums critical analysis

One of the elements that literature allow the readers to use is the imagination in order to visualize what the author message is in his story or poem. George spares Lennie from Curley's wrath by shooting Lennie in the back of the head after reciting their shared dream of owning a farm one final time Extra Facts. She notices as his mouth grows sure and knowing, and she asks him where he sleeps, envying his carefree life, a way of living which most people believe to be impossible for a woman. Not only is she alone but the farm itself, even the Salinas Valley, seems to be isolated. Elisa relationship with her husband is more functional and passive; like a relationship between siblings. The reader gets a taste of all complications that George and Lennie face as they move around the country in search of work.

Next

The chrysanthemums literary analysis. The Chrysanthemums: Themes, Symbolism & Analysis. 2022

the chrysanthemums critical analysis

She expresses an explicit longing to live an independent and free life just as he does; however, this is unheard of for a woman and the tinker reminds her of this. One good indication that Elisa and Henry aren't sexually active is that they have no children. The husband and the tinker do not seem to understand her passionate view of her flowers. The chrysanthemums should take root in about a month, but the most important thing that he must remember to tell his customer is to cut the chrysanthemums about eight inches from the ground in July, before they bloom in late September. Men make up mysteries when they can not understand women and may feel threatened.

Next

The Chrysanthemums

the chrysanthemums critical analysis

The Chrysanthemums Literary Analysis Essay The Chrysanthemums is shaped by the common gender roles that is present in society. For the first time, Elisa becomes aware that her interaction with the tinker was not what it appeared to be. In her mind, the sight of them seals her fate, and she cries 'like an old woman,' as if she finally realizes that she herself is the flower pot and not the chrysanthemums. The theme of gender inequality is present, and can specifically be seen in the conversation Elisa has with the man from the wagon, in which he says the life he lives is not for a woman. As Elisa stands and watches the tinker leave, she audibly whispers good-bye, startling herself with the sound of her voice.

Next

Analysis: The Chrysanthemums by John Steinbeck Essay Example

the chrysanthemums critical analysis

She is strong because of her manly qualities. Her eyes try to avoid them but she cannot, and alongside the chrysanthemums, her children, lie her dreams. Henry insists he is only fooling around and promises her dinner at the Cominos Hotel. It would be good for both of us. This woman has begged the stranger to bring her any if he ever happens to discover some and, now miraculously he has found some. Elisa cherishes the flowers like a mother protecting her son or daughter.

Next

The Chrysanthemums Critical Essays

the chrysanthemums critical analysis

Elisa becomes preoccupied with the fights, shedding light on her clear interest in the masculine sport. Both the setting and overall mood of the characters, support the comparison of Emily to her Chrysanthemums. She is in her thirties, and it generally is difficult for a woman at her age to bear children. Elisa has a talent for growing things, and is proud of her ability to cultivate the biggest chrysanthemums in the whole valley. My initial observations about the story, were also that the flowers symbolized Elisa in many ways. It creates a desire for the reader to go on reading by absorbing them in the middle of the story, wanting to know what happens next. It is obvious that Elisa spends most of her time alone, and even a passing stranger is a welcomed sight.

Next

The Chrysanthemums Critical Analysis

the chrysanthemums critical analysis

No doubt she feels these activities would provide her with a sense of accomplishment since everyone seems to ignore her potential as a woman. This story is a good depiction of the past judgment of women. Elisa is depicted as having a masculine appearance when she is working in the garden. He even suggests that they attend the fights afterward. He notices her work with the flowers and takes a chance, asking her about her prize chrysanthemums. Some women were fortunate to receive formal schooling. Washington: Washington State University, 2011.

Next